Extended lifecycles and their impact on fleet management
The trucking industry is undergoing significant changes, particularly concerning fleet management and equipment lifecycles. As economic pressures mount, many fleets find themselves in a precarious position, balancing the need for efficiency with rising costs. Understanding the implications of extending equipment lifecycles is crucial for fleet operators to ensure sustainability and profitability in a challenging market.
Understanding the Challenges of Extended Equipment Lifecycles
Recent discussions at the American Trucking Associations’ (ATA) Management Conference & Exhibition highlighted that many fleets are merely trying to survive amid economic uncertainties. A significant takeaway from the conference was the vulnerability of fleets that have delayed essential maintenance while extending the operational life of their equipment.
Bob Costello, ATA's chief economist, emphasized the risks associated with deferring maintenance investments. He stated, “It’s going to catch up with you at some point.” This sentiment resonates with many smaller fleets that have had to cut costs drastically due to market pressures, leading to potentially severe repercussions.
Cheryl Garcia, senior vice-president at U.S. Bank, echoed this concern, stressing the importance of tracking maintenance expenses. She noted, “If you put off maintenance, or you’re not keeping track of your expenses, it’s going to cost you even more in the future.” This reality underscores the critical nature of proactive maintenance strategies.
The Financial Implications of Deferred Maintenance
Engaging with Brian Antonellis, a lifecycle expert and senior vice-president at Fleet Advantage, sheds light on how extending equipment lifecycles impacts maintenance and repair (M&R) costs. Antonellis pointed out that many fleets do not fully grasp the implications of their decisions regarding equipment lifecycles and maintenance.
He explained that as trucks age, several factors contribute to increasing operational costs:
- Fuel Economy Degradation: A truck that initially achieves 7 miles per gallon (mpg) may begin to lose efficiency as it accumulates higher mileage, particularly beyond the 450,000-500,000 mile mark.
- Rising M&R Costs: Costs can escalate from approximately 2-2.5 cents per mile in the first year to around 12.5-15 cents per mile by year five, assuming an annual distance of 100,000 miles.
- Component Failures: Older vehicles are prone to failures in critical components like engines, transmissions, and diesel particulate filters (DPFs), leading to unpredictable maintenance expenses.
The cyclical nature of these costs can trap fleets in a pattern of spending. Antonellis advises fleets to evaluate what extending the lifecycle truly saves in capital costs against the rising maintenance expenses. This assessment is vital for making informed decisions about fleet management.
Evaluating the Cost of Delayed Equipment Acquisition
As many fleets hesitate to acquire new equipment, the average age of trucks in service continues to rise. Antonellis recommends running detailed calculations to assess the cost per mile in terms of fuel efficiency and maintenance expenses. He notes that modern trucks typically improve fuel economy by 1.5-2% annually.
Fleets must consider how their aging equipment compares to new models, which can offer significant fuel efficiency advantages. For fleets waiting to acquire new equipment, understanding the financial implications is essential:
- Assess the potential increase in fuel costs due to decreased fuel efficiency in older trucks.
- Calculate the anticipated M&R costs as the vehicle ages.
- Compare these costs to the acquisition costs of new, more efficient models.
To illustrate, if a fleet is currently operating a truck that gets 7 mpg, and a new model achieves 9 mpg, the fuel savings over a year can be substantial, particularly at high mileage.
The Economics of New Equipment Acquisition
The cost of new trucks has surged, influenced by supply chain disruptions and evolving emissions regulations. Antonellis pointed out that where a day cab might have cost around $120,000 five years ago, the same vehicle could now be priced at approximately $160,000.
This increased acquisition cost raises important questions about the value of new equipment:
- Efficiency Gains: New trucks offer significantly better fuel economy, which justifies the higher purchase price over time.
- Cost of Ownership: The total cost of ownership includes not just purchase price but also ongoing maintenance, repairs, and downtime.
- Investment Timing: The optimal time to refresh equipment is typically around the four- to six-year mark, balancing acquisition costs with operational efficiency.
Despite the challenges posed by rising costs, Antonellis is optimistic about the benefits of investing in new trucks, particularly when considering the long-term savings associated with fuel economy and reduced maintenance costs.
Future Outlook: Will Equipment Costs Decrease?
With ongoing uncertainty surrounding emissions regulations and tariffs, the future price of new trucks remains a point of speculation. Antonellis firmly believes that costs will not decrease, but rather will continue to climb due to new technological advancements and regulatory compliance.
Historically, the industry has seen annual price increases of 1.8-2.4%. However, since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, these increases have surged, with some OEMs reporting price hikes of up to 10% annually. This trend signifies that fleets must be prepared for a continuously rising cost structure.
Investing in Knowledge and Resources
The complexities of managing extended lifecycles and understanding the financial implications of fleet operations necessitate ongoing education and resource investment. Antonellis encourages fleet managers to engage with analytics and industry benchmarks to make informed decisions.
For those interested in further exploring these topics, a free webinar is scheduled for November 20 at 3 p.m. EST, featuring industry experts discussing how to manage extended lifecycles without compromising maintenance or safety. Register here.
In conclusion, as the trucking industry navigates these challenging times, understanding the implications of equipment lifecycles on maintenance and repair costs is critical. Fleets must strategically evaluate their operations and investments to ensure they are positioned for sustained success.
Leave a Reply